Standards Site

 
 
Schemes of Work
QCA

Citizenship at key stage 3    (Year 7-9)

Unit 05: How the law protects animals - a local-to-global study
Section 2: How does the law protect animal welfare?

QCA

Objectives

Children should learn:
  • to reflect on an issue of public concern and consider how the law relates to it
  • to consider some of the social, moral and political dimensions of an issue such as animal welfare
  • to consider different ways of trying to achieve changes in the law
  • to consider the part people play in creating social pressure, both individually and by joining together
  • about the main stages through which a bill passes before it becomes law
  • about the role of public opinion in politics and in influencing government agendas
  • to identify bias and objectivity in texts (NSE)

Activities

Outcomes

Children:
  • Ask the pupils to think about an issue such as animal welfare. They could list examples of cruelty to animals, and discuss their views on topics like factory farming and the use of animals in scientific research. With the pupils, identify and collate the range of views on any issues discussed.
  • Give the pupils a list of possible influences on the way animals are treated, eg local councils (which enforce regulations), national government (which develops policies and laws), the media, public opinion, the opinion of particular individuals. Ask them to discuss which of these carries the most weight. (Note that the same list would apply to most of the issues teachers might select.)
  • Ask pupils, in groups, to discuss and investigate the role of voluntary organisations and pressure groups. They could look at key groups, considering the following questions:
    • What do you know about the groups and any similar organisations you have heard of?
    • Who do the groups try to put pressure on?
    • What methods do the groups use?
    • Are all the methods used by pressure groups equally acceptable, eg targeting individuals?
    • What information do the groups publish, and what are their current campaigns?
  • Pupils analyse the literature produced by pressure groups to discover what kinds of arguments are used, and whether it provides balanced views or seems biased.
  • With the pupils, consider how laws are made. Focus on a law that links with the chosen issue, eg the Animal Scientific Procedures Act 1986, and examine how it came to be passed and how it was affected by public opinion. Ask pupils to consider:
    • What happens when the Government announces that it will bring in a new law?
    • What consultations does it carry out?
    • How do people try to influence what the law says?
    • Can individuals make a difference to the law-making process? If so, how?
  • offer reasons why an issue such as animal welfare is of public concern
  • understand what voluntary organisations are and how they operate, and describe their relationship to government in terms of making and changing the law
  • understand the term ‘pressure group’
  • describe different methods of protesting against legislation and discuss in outline some of the legal and moral issues these raise
  • identify reasons both for and against an issue, eg animal testing, and express a personal opinion on the issue orally and in writing
  • research an issue using literature from pressure groups, and identify reasons for treating such information with caution
  • describe in simple terms how a bill passes through Parliament and becomes law

Points to note

  • Remind pupils of the ground rules for discussion that were established at the start of year 7 (see introductory unit 1 'Citizenship - what's it all about?')
  • Useful contacts for researching different views on these issues include:
  • The Citizenship Foundation publishes material showing how the Animal Scientific Procedures Act 1986 went through the parliamentary process before becoming law. It also offers a number of case studies illustrating the different legal and illegal campaigning tactics used by animal rights groups.
  • Link with NSE: year 7 R9, year 8 R6, year 9 R6

Sections in this unit

<< previous section next section >>
This unit is divided into sections. Each section contains a sequence of activities with related objectives and outcomes. You can view this unit by moving through the sections or print/download the whole unit.
1. How does the law protect our pets?
2. How does the law protect animal welfare?
3. How does Parliament debate an issue?
4. How is animal welfare of concern internationally?